A generous private estate lawn bordered by mature trees in muted autumn color, with a corner of gray stone terrace in the foreground.

In Country Club of the South, Start With the Price of the Lot

In August, a bank-owned lot on Covington Cove in Country Club of the South drew multiple offers. The listing called for highest and best by noon on Wednesday, Aug. 12, 2026. The listing described 460 Covington Cove as a 0.72-acre homesite with no house on it, and it closed in early September for $827,500, according to Georgia MLS data.

That sale gives a buyer comparing gated golf communities in Johns Creek a useful yardstick. In Country Club of the South, the dirt alone is worth about $830,000. Every home sale this year can be read as that lot plus whatever the house adds. Seen that way, the 2026 sales point one way. The age of the house barely matters, because nearly every house here is about the same age. What a buyer pays above the lot depends mostly on how much renovation the house has had.

A Community Built in One Era

Country Club of the South was founded in 1985 and covers 733 homesites on more than 900 acres. Its Jack Nicklaus course opened in 1987. The homes that changed hands in 2026 were built between 1987 and 1999. When every house on the market dates from the same dozen years, a newer house is not something a buyer can pay extra for. The lot gets the community, the gate and the course, and the house is whatever a previous owner did with it.

At the small end, the house adds surprisingly little. 4030 Newgate Court is a 4,567-square-foot home built in 1993. It came to market on May 21 at $1.1 million, dropped to $1.05 million on July 30 and closed in late September at $1.0 million. The listing described a renovated kitchen and updated baths. Take out the $827,500 lot price and the house itself accounts for roughly $172,500, or about $38 a square foot.

1070 Abingdon Lane fits the same pattern. The 4,341-square-foot home was built in 1990 and marketed as a house with room for modernization. It closed on Nov. 5, and its last recorded asking price was $990,000. A buyer paying near that figure is paying mostly for the homesite and getting the house as a starting point.

Lots differ in size, slope and position on the course, so one lot sale is a rough measure. The gaps it shows between houses are still large.

Two Houses on Merriweather Woods, Two Weeks Apart

3977 and 3915 Merriweather Woods are about as close a comparison as this community allows. They are on the same street, built three years apart, and both are over 8,000 square feet.

3977 Merriweather Woods was built in 1991 and has 9,332 square feet. Its listing said more than $1 million had gone into renovations and improvements. It sold on Sept. 21 for $2.455 million, above its $2.395 million list price, after 73 days on the market.

3915 Merriweather Woods was built in 1994 and has 8,312 square feet. Its listing pointed to a newer roof, new flooring and two newer HVAC systems, and described the finishes as updated without calling the home fully renovated. It listed on Aug. 5, was cut from $1.8 million and closed on Oct. 6 at $1.78 million.

The two sales are $675,000 apart. After the lot comes out, the renovated house brought about $174 a square foot. The house with new systems brought about $115. A roof and HVAC systems protect a house's value, but buyers here paid noticeably more for the kitchen, baths and finishes they would see on a walkthrough.

Two Houses on Westbourne Way, Six Months Apart

Westbourne Way shows the same gap, plus a difference in how long each house took to sell.

2005 Westbourne Way was built in 1996 and has 6,505 square feet. Its listing highlighted a pool and spa but did not describe a full renovation. It opened at $1.85 million, went under contract at $1.7495 million and closed on April 28 for $1.6 million, after 412 days on the market. After subtracting the lot, the house brought about $119 a square foot, close to the 3915 Merriweather Woods figure.

2007 Westbourne Way was built in 1999 and has 8,070 square feet. It was marketed as a fully renovated home and closed on Oct. 29 for $2.215 million. After subtracting the lot, that comes to about $172 a square foot, nearly the same as the renovated house on Merriweather Woods.

Two different streets and two different seasons produced two nearly identical spreads. Across these four sales, renovated houses brought roughly $170 a square foot above the lot. Houses that were mainly kept up brought about $115 to $120.

Where Asking Prices Ran Ahead

Renovation brings a higher price, but it does not make a house sell quickly. 1020 Abingdon Lane, built in 1989 with 9,166 square feet, was marketed for its modern livability and updated finishes. It sold on May 1 for $2.55 million, above its $2.475 million ask, but only after 235 days on the market. 1245 Stuart Ridge was built in 1996 with 9,697 square feet and brought the year's highest price, $3.025 million on Aug. 14. Its asking price started at $3.4 million and later showed $3.195 million, and the home spent 234 days on the market. After subtracting the lot, Stuart Ridge works out to about $227 a square foot, the highest of any 2026 sale here, and it still sold for $375,000 below its opening ask.

In the middle of the market, sellers made smaller adjustments. 750 Sturges Way, built in 1987, was listed with an updated kitchen and a redesigned fireplace. Its price history shows a $2.1 million ask, and it sold on Oct. 14 for $1.95 million. 950 Tiverton Lane, built in 1988 with 5,577 square feet and marketed as completely updated, sold on Oct. 30 for $1.7 million after a $1.725 million asking price and 77 days on the market. Both houses work out to about $156 a square foot above the lot. One is a full renovation and the other has a kitchen-focused update, and both landed close to the renovated range.

The 2026 Sales With the Lot Subtracted

Measured as total price per square foot, this year's sales run from about $214 to $312, a wide range for houses built within about a dozen years of each other. Taking out the lot shows where that spread comes from. The final column subtracts the $827,500 homesite sale from each price and divides by the home's square footage.

Address Closed Price Sq. ft. Built Listing condition Above-lot $/sq. ft.
4030 Newgate Court Sept. 2026 $1,000,000 4,567 1993 Updated kitchen and baths ~$38
3915 Merriweather Woods Oct. 6 $1,780,000 8,312 1994 Newer roof, floors, HVAC ~$115
2005 Westbourne Way Apr. 28 $1,600,000 6,505 1996 Pool and spa, no full renovation ~$119
750 Sturges Way Oct. 14 $1,950,000 7,216 1987 Updated kitchen, redesigned fireplace ~$156
950 Tiverton Lane Oct. 30 $1,700,000 5,577 1988 Completely updated ~$156
2007 Westbourne Way Oct. 29 $2,215,000 8,070 1999 Fully renovated ~$172
3977 Merriweather Woods Sept. 21 $2,455,000 9,332 1991 $1M+ in improvements ~$174
1020 Abingdon Lane May 1 $2,550,000 9,166 1989 Updated finishes ~$188
1245 Stuart Ridge Aug. 14 $3,025,000 9,697 1996 Not described ~$227

Sorted this way, the order follows the condition column almost exactly. Size and build year explain much less. For a buyer, this means a list price in Country Club of the South is mostly a price for a lot and a level of renovation. A dated house near the lot price is a lot purchase with a renovation budget still to come. A finished house near the top of the table has already had that money spent on it.

What the Lot Price Includes

The homesite price includes what surrounds the house, and that has been changing. Arcis Golf bought the Country Club of the South along with two other north Fulton clubs, a deal The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported in June 2025. Arcis's transformation page for the club lists drainage and creek work on the course, upgraded practice areas, an updated fitness center, improvements to the dining patio and the Magnolia Room, and resurfaced tennis and pickleball courts with LED lighting. The club sells golf, racquet and social memberships as separate categories, and the 18-hole, par-72 Nicklaus course is still the community's centerpiece.

Those club improvements belong to the whole community and change no single house. Each owner still decides on their own kitchen and baths, and those decisions show up in the sales above. For a wider look at the city around the gate, the Johns Creek neighborhood guide covers the rest of the area.

For owners in Country Club of the South, the first useful number is what their homesite is worth, and the second is how much their renovation adds above it. Stevens Residential can run the same lot-and-renovation math on your street. Before you list, or before you make an offer on a dated house, schedule a free market consultation, or start with a home valuation.

Work With Us

For the best service and results when it comes to all of your real estate needs, reach out anytime.

Follow Us on Instagram